Beyond white guilt: The real challenge for Black‑White relations in Australia
Beyond white guilt: The real challenge for Black‑White relations in Australia
Sarah Maddison; Allen & Unwin; 2011;
240pp; $27.99 (paperback).
Unsettling the settler state: Creativity and resistance in Indigenous settler-state governance
Sarah Maddison and Morgan Brigg (eds); The Federation Press; 2011;
256pp; $49.95 (paperback).
I had a mixed response to reading Sarah Maddison’s recent work Beyond White Guilt. Maddison, I believe, is accurate to depict the issue of Indigenous – non-Indigenous relations as crucial for Australia. Indeed, the nation and state are intimately tied to a colonial history embedded in whiteness and the denial of Indigenous sovereignty. Personally, I am not sure that white guilt is the biggest challenge. However, I do agree that this is an important issue worthy of Maddison’s keen analysis and she successfully hinges her argument around an examination of this issue. At times, I did feel that I was reading with a sense of de je vu, in that many of the issues covered have been written about and debated widely in Australia. Indeed, Henry Reynolds and others have written extensively in the area of colonial history and past policies leading to contemporary implications for Indigenous people and all who reside in the country called Australia. In this sense, the book is not difficult to read, because the arguments are familiar, thereby allowing the author to provide an appraisal of their contemporary form and to give a unique twist.


